
Ethereum Store of Value: Lubin Backs Buterin as BitMine Reports a $6.3 Billion Loss
Ethereum co-founder Joseph Lubin has publicly endorsed the view that ETH could function as a legitimate store of value, aligning himself with recent arguments made by fellow co-founder Vitalik Buterin. The endorsement, reported by Crowdfund Insider on November 12, lands at a moment when Ethereum’s investment case is being debated more fiercely than at any point in years. ETH is down sharply, its ETFs are bleeding money, and network activity is cooling. Into that gloom, Lubin has offered a fundamentally different way of thinking about the asset: not as a token whose value depends on transaction fees, but as a form of money in its own right, comparable in its role to gold and Bitcoin. The Ethereum store of value argument is not new, but it has rarely been made this directly by figures of Lubin’s standing. If ETH is a store of value, then its price should be judged on its ability to preserve and grow purchasing power over time, not on quarterly fee revenue or short-term usage statistics. That is a bold claim, and it is being tested in real time by the market. On the same day Lubin’s comments were reported, news emerged that BitMine, the largest corporate holder of ETH, had reported a net loss of $6.3 billion for fiscal 2026, mostly in unrealised losses as ETH prices fell. The contrast could hardly be sharper: one of Ethereum’s founders arguing that ETH is sound money, while the biggest corporate buyer of ETH reports a multi-billion-dollar paper loss from holding it. The Lubin Buterin ETH debate, and the treasury results that sit alongside it, frame the most important question in Ethereum today: is ETH money, or is it just a technology stock in disguise?
Ethereum Store of Value: What Lubin Actually Said
Lubin’s case for ETH as a store of value rests on a set of properties he says the asset shares with gold and Bitcoin. According to the Crowdfund Insider report, Lubin argued that ETH can preserve and grow purchasing power during periods of elevated inflation and economic and social instability. That is the core test of any store of value: does holding it protect you when the money in your bank account is losing value? Lubin compared ETH favourably to gold and Bitcoin on this point, and he drew a sharper distinction with traditional money. Like gold and Bitcoin, he noted, ETH is not debt-based or credit-based money. It does not depend on a borrower repaying a loan or a government honouring a promise, and its value does not rest on the creditworthiness of any issuer, because there is no issuer in the traditional sense. Lubin also pointed to censorship resistance, arguing that ETH is censorship-resistant on its base layer, including in its decentralised finance smart contracts. That matters for a store of value because an asset you cannot freely hold, move or use is a poor refuge in a crisis. He added that ETH’s supply is disinflationary under ordinary conditions, and can potentially become deflationary during periods of high network activity, when more ETH is burned in fees than is issued to validators. Lubin also noted that ETH serves as collateral across the on-chain economy and hosts the majority of stablecoin activity, giving it a practical role in finance that gold does not have. Finally, he argued that ETH is the base money of a growing ecosystem, one that retail users, corporations and eventually governments will need to hold.
Buterin’s Case: Why the Fee-Burn Story Was Never Enough
Lubin’s endorsement builds directly on a thread posted by Vitalik Buterin on November 8, in which Buterin argued that focusing on ETH as a store of value makes more sense than treating it primarily as a fee-burning token. The distinction matters because, for years, a large part of the bullish case for ETH rested on the fee-burn mechanism introduced by EIP-1559. Under that system, a portion of the fees paid by users is burned, permanently removing ETH from circulation. The theory was simple: the more the network is used, the more ETH is burned, and the scarcer the remaining ETH becomes. Buterin’s thread challenged that story. He argued that the fee-burn narrative was never as robust as it appeared, because much of the past fee revenue came from speculative activity inside crypto itself, activity that declines when prices fall. When markets are booming, traders pay high fees to trade tokens and chase new opportunities. When markets fall, that activity dries up, and with it goes the fee revenue that was supposed to make ETH scarce. A store-of-value case built on fees that vanish in a downturn is, in Buterin’s view, a fragile foundation. He endorsed retaining the EIP-1559 burn mechanism, but he warned against disappointment if burns stay below the level needed to offset new issuance. The implication is important. If the burn cannot reliably make ETH deflationary, then the case for holding ETH must rest on something else: its monetary properties, its role as collateral, and its position as the base asset of a growing on-chain economy. That is exactly the case Lubin has now endorsed.
Gold, Bitcoin and ETH: The Case for Non-Debt Money
The most striking part of the Lubin Buterin ETH argument is the comparison with gold and Bitcoin, and the emphasis on what ETH is not: debt-based money. Almost all of the money in the modern economy is created through lending. When a bank makes a loan, it creates new money, and when the loan is repaid, that money disappears. The system works well in good times, but it means the money in your account ultimately depends on a chain of borrowers repaying their debts and on institutions remaining solvent. Gold sits outside that system. Nobody owes you anything for a bar of gold, and its value does not depend on a counterparty keeping a promise. Bitcoin was designed with the same property in mind: its supply is fixed, it is not issued as debt, and holding it does not require trusting any institution. Lubin’s argument is that ETH belongs in the same category. It is not issued as a loan, it is not a claim on anyone’s balance sheet, and its supply is governed by transparent protocol rules rather than by the decisions of a central bank or a commercial lender. That does not make ETH identical to gold or Bitcoin. Gold has thousands of years of history as a store of value. Bitcoin has a fixed supply cap of 21 million coins, while ETH has no hard cap, though its issuance is limited and its supply can shrink when network activity is high. Critics will also note that ETH is more complex than either gold or Bitcoin, and that complexity brings risks of its own. But the comparison is doing real work in the debate. It reframes ETH from a technology product into a monetary asset, and asks investors to judge it by monetary standards: does it preserve purchasing power, does it survive crises, and does it remain usable when institutions fail?
BitMine $6.3 Billion Loss: The Treasury Trade Under Pressure
While Lubin and Buterin were making the philosophical case for ETH, the market was delivering a harsh verdict on the companies that have bet their balance sheets on it. BitMine, the largest corporate holder of ETH, reported a net loss of $6.3 billion for fiscal 2026, according to a report on Binance Square on November 12 citing Foresight News via X. The loss was mostly unrealised, meaning it reflects the fall in the value of the ETH BitMine holds rather than cash actually spent. BitMine holds 6.07 million ETH, equal to 4.97 percent of the total supply, putting it close to the 5 percent target set by Tom Lee, who is associated with the company. At current prices, that is an enormous position, and when ETH falls by more than half from its highs, the paper losses on a holding of that size are inevitably enormous too. The company remains down by around $6.2 billion on its position, a figure that captures the scale of the drawdown in a single number. The contrast with SharpLink, another Ethereum treasury company, is instructive. SharpLink reported third-quarter net income of $750 million, with around 90 percent of that figure coming from unrealised gains. The difference between the two companies is largely a matter of timing and entry price, but the comparison shows how violently treasury-company results swing with the ETH price. When ETH rises, these companies report spectacular paper profits. When it falls, they report spectacular paper losses. That volatility is the central risk of the treasury model. A company that holds nearly 5 percent of the entire ETH supply is, in effect, a leveraged bet on the price of a single asset, and its reported earnings will rise and fall with that asset alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Ethereum store of value argument? The Ethereum store of value argument, endorsed by Joseph Lubin and Vitalik Buterin, holds that ETH can preserve and grow purchasing power like gold and Bitcoin, because it is not debt-based money, is censorship-resistant, has disinflationary supply, and serves as collateral across the on-chain economy.
Why did Buterin say the fee-burn story was weak? Buterin argued in a November 8 thread that much past fee revenue came from speculative crypto-internal activity that declines when prices fall, so the EIP-1559 burn was never as robust a foundation for ETH’s value as it appeared, and he warned against disappointment if burns stay below the level needed to offset issuance.
What is the BitMine $6.3 billion loss? The BitMine $6.3 billion loss is the net loss BitMine reported for fiscal 2026, mostly unrealised losses as ETH prices fell. BitMine holds 6.07 million ETH, equal to 4.97 percent of supply, and remains down by around $6.2 billion on its position.
How did SharpLink perform by comparison? SharpLink reported third-quarter net income of $750 million, with around 90 percent of that figure coming from unrealised gains, showing how sharply Ethereum treasury-company results swing with the ETH price.
Source: Crowdfund Insider
—
—
Related reading on MM Crypto Analysis Web
- Ethereum ETF Outflows Stretch to 23 Straight Days as $1.61 Billion Exits in October
- Vitalik Buterin’s Lean Ethereum: Bunker Mode, Quantum-Proof Crypto and a Decade of Survival
- Ethereum Stakers Refuse to Sell as Exit Queue Collapses 86%
More in Ethereum on MM Crypto Analysis Web.
Pingback: Ethereum Post-Quantum 2027: Ethlabs Proposes pqai27