Loading live prices…
DeFi

Coinbase EU Policy Chief Warns MiCA Suitability Tests Could Push DeFi Users Offshore

Coinbase’s head of EU policy, Roeland Van der Stappen, has warned that new European oversight of decentralised finance could redirect crypto users to platforms with fewer investor safeguards, fragmenting liquidity across the bloc. His warning lands as regulators in Brussels weigh how far the Markets in Crypto-Assets framework, known as MiCA, should extend into DeFi, and it raises a question that will shape the next phase of European crypto policy: how do you protect users of open, permissionless protocols without pushing them towards venues that offer no protection at all?

Advertisement

The debate centres on suitability tests, the checks that regulated firms use to judge whether a product fits a particular customer. Under the proposals now under discussion, platforms that give customers access to DeFi protocols could be required to run such tests before letting users trade, lend or provide liquidity. Van der Stappen argues that applying the same test to every DeFi activity, regardless of risk, would be a mistake, and that the result would be fewer Europeans using regulated European services and more of them seeking out platforms beyond the reach of EU rules. This Coinbase EU DeFi warning, and the wider debate over ESMA DeFi regulation, will shape how Brussels writes the next phase of MiCA.

What the proposed MiCA DeFi suitability tests would require

The idea of extending MiCA to DeFi has been building for months. In September, the European Securities and Markets Authority, ESMA, recommended a new regulated service category for firms providing customer access to DeFi protocols, in its response to the European Commission’s consultation on MiCA. The recommendation would bring a layer of firms that currently sit outside the regulatory perimeter into the supervised world, requiring them to meet standards on conduct, disclosure and customer protection before they can serve European users.

The European Banking Authority, the EBA, separately urged the Commission in September to examine rules for crypto lending and borrowing, including suitability tests for platforms facilitating access to DeFi lending protocols. Together, the two proposals sketch a future in which the gateway to DeFi, rather than the protocols themselves, becomes the regulated point. The protocols would remain open and decentralised, but the firms that help ordinary users reach them would face obligations similar to those that apply to traditional investment firms. For the industry, that is a significant shift, and the details of how it is implemented will decide whether the new rules protect users or simply inconvenience them.

Advertisement

Why Coinbase says blanket MiCA DeFi suitability tests miss the real risks

Van der Stappen’s central argument is that blanket suitability tests ignore risk differences between DeFi activities. A stablecoin swap, he argued, carries vastly different exposure than leveraged lending, yet the two would be treated identically under a one-size-fits-all test. Swapping one stablecoin for another is a low-volatility transaction with limited downside, while borrowing against crypto collateral with leverage can wipe out a position in a sharp market move. Treating them the same would mean either over-regulating the simple activity or under-regulating the risky one, and neither outcome serves users well.

The point matters because suitability tests are not a light-touch requirement. They ask firms to collect information about a customer’s knowledge, experience, financial situation and objectives, and to judge whether a product is appropriate before allowing the trade. Applied sensibly, they can stop inexperienced users from taking on risks they do not understand. Applied indiscriminately to every on-chain interaction, they could turn simple transactions into lengthy compliance exercises, discouraging users from using regulated services at all. Van der Stappen’s concern is that the friction would fall hardest on the safest activities, while the riskiest users would simply move elsewhere.

Lending, liquidity provision and on-chain swaps: the activities most exposed

Not all DeFi activities would be affected equally. Lending, liquidity provision and on-chain swaps face the most direct restrictions under the proposals, because they are the activities that most ordinary users encounter when they first use DeFi. Lending lets users earn interest by supplying assets to a protocol or borrow against their holdings. Liquidity provision lets them earn fees by depositing pairs of assets into a trading pool. On-chain swaps let them exchange one token for another without an intermediary. Each of these is a gateway activity, and each would be caught by rules aimed at firms that provide customer access to protocols.

The concentration of attention on these three activities reflects how regulators think about risk. Lending involves credit and liquidation risk, liquidity provision involves the risk of impermanent loss when token prices diverge, and swaps involve execution and price risk. All three can be explained and managed, but they require different safeguards. A disclosure that makes sense for a leveraged loan is meaningless for a simple swap, and a test designed for a complex derivative is overkill for exchanging one stablecoin for another. That is why Van der Stappen is calling for safeguards tailored to the risk of each specific activity, rather than a single test applied to everything.

Advertisement

The ESMA and EBA proposals behind the debate

Understanding the warning requires understanding where the proposals came from. ESMA’s September response to the European Commission’s MiCA consultation recommended a new regulated service category for firms providing customer access to DeFi protocols, a move that would formalise the role of intermediaries in a world that was designed to work without them. The Commission is now weighing that recommendation as part of its broader review of MiCA, and the decision it takes will set the direction of European DeFi policy for years to come.

The EBA’s contribution focused on lending and borrowing, an area where the risks to consumers are most acute. Its September call for the Commission to examine rules for crypto lending and borrowing, including suitability tests for platforms facilitating access to DeFi lending protocols, reflects concern about leveraged positions and liquidation cascades. When a borrower is liquidated in a falling market, the losses can be sudden and total, and regulators want to know that the person taking that risk understood what they were doing. The challenge is to write rules that catch that risk without catching everything else as well.

How Europeans actually use DeFi today

The debate is not happening in a vacuum. A 2026 survey by Adan and Ipsos showed that 49% of French crypto buyers preferred accessing DeFi through centralised exchanges, while only 14% used personal wallets. That split is revealing: most users already reach DeFi through a familiar, centralised gateway rather than interacting with protocols directly. If those gateways become harder to use, or if they withdraw DeFi access because the compliance burden is too high, the users who depend on them will have to choose between learning to use personal wallets and finding another gateway, possibly one outside the EU.

The market data points in a similar direction. A Chainalysis report released on Monday documented a modest decline in crypto activity in Germany driven by reduced DEX volume, a reminder that decentralised exchange activity can fall quickly when conditions change. Across the EU overall, crypto activity grew 2.2% in the 12 months ending June 2026, so the bloc as a whole is still expanding, but the German figures show that growth is not uniform. If regulation makes regulated access harder, the activity that remains may increasingly happen on platforms that European regulators cannot see, let alone supervise.

Advertisement

A proportionate framework: what Coinbase wants instead

Van der Stappen is not arguing against regulation. He called for a proportionate framework with safeguards tailored to specific activity risk levels, a position that accepts the need for oversight while rejecting the idea that every DeFi interaction carries the same danger. In practice, that would mean lighter checks for low-risk activities like stablecoin swaps and more rigorous tests for leveraged lending and complex positions. It would also mean judging firms on the risks they actually create, rather than on whether they touch DeFi at all.

The argument will resonate with policymakers who want Europe to remain competitive in digital assets, but it will face resistance from those who believe that the only safe approach is to regulate every gateway in the same way. The outcome will matter beyond Europe, because the EU’s framework is watched closely by regulators elsewhere. A proportionate model could become a template for other jurisdictions, while a rigid one could become a cautionary tale. For now, the debate is open, and the Commission’s response to the ESMA and EBA proposals will be the next moment that counts.

Frequently asked questions

What are the proposed MiCA DeFi suitability tests? They are checks that platforms providing customer access to DeFi protocols would have to run to judge whether a product fits a particular user. ESMA recommended a new regulated service category for such firms in September, and the EBA separately urged rules for crypto lending and borrowing, including suitability tests for platforms facilitating access to DeFi lending protocols.

Why does Coinbase oppose blanket suitability tests? Coinbase’s head of EU policy, Roeland Van der Stappen, argues that blanket tests ignore risk differences. A stablecoin swap carries vastly different exposure than leveraged lending, yet both would be treated identically. He warns that over-regulating simple activities could push users to platforms with fewer investor safeguards and fragment liquidity across the EU.

Advertisement

Which DeFi activities face the most direct restrictions? Lending, liquidity provision and on-chain swaps face the most direct restrictions, because they are the activities most ordinary users encounter when they first use DeFi, and they are the focus of the ESMA and EBA proposals.

How do Europeans access DeFi today? A 2026 Adan-Ipsos survey showed 49% of French crypto buyers preferred accessing DeFi through centralised exchanges, while only 14% used personal wallets. Across the EU overall, crypto activity grew 2.2% in the 12 months ending June 2026, although a Chainalysis report released on Monday documented a modest decline in Germany driven by reduced DEX volume.

Source: Gokhshtein.

Related reading on MM Crypto Analysis Web

More in DeFi on MM Crypto Analysis Web.

Advertisement
Advertisement

MM Crypto Team

MM Crypto Team covers crypto news, prices and market analysis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement