Loading live prices…
Regulation

Banks Ask FinCEN to Bring DeFi Under Bank Secrecy Act Reporting

America’s largest banks want the reporting net thrown wider over crypto, including decentralized finance, the part of the market that has so far escaped it almost entirely. In a November 6 letter, the Bank Policy Institute, which represents large banks operating in the United States, asked the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network and the Office of Foreign Assets Control to designate digital-asset service providers and people who operate or control decentralized finance arrangements as financial institutions under the Bank Secrecy Act. The request follows a run of withdrawals in which the Treasury Department stepped back from three crypto data-collection proposals in about five weeks. The banks are asking the government to move the compliance burden they carry onto crypto intermediaries, arguing that those intermediaries hold the customer records, wallet data and transaction details that banks never see. The letter carries no force of law, but it opens a major fight over who must identify the other side of a decentralized transaction.

Advertisement

Three withdrawals in five weeks

The banks’ letter answers a run of retreats by the Treasury Department that began in early October. On October 5, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, known as FinCEN, withdrew two proposals. The first dated from December 2020 and would have required banks and money services businesses to verify identities and keep records when customers transacted with unhosted wallets, the self-custody wallets users control themselves rather than through an exchange. The second dated from 2023 and would have treated international crypto mixing as a class of transactions of primary money-laundering concern under Section 311 of the USA PATRIOT Act. FinCEN tied both withdrawals to the administration’s deregulatory agenda. The third retreat came on November 6, the same day as the banks’ letter, when FinCEN and the Federal Reserve Board pulled the 2020 plan to cut the cross-border recordkeeping and Travel Rule threshold from 3,000 dollars to 250 dollars. The agencies said more than five years had passed, the crypto industry had changed, and fresh public input would help. The withdrawal takes effect with Federal Register publication on November 9, leaving the 3,000-dollar trigger in force. All three proposals put the work on institutions already inside the Bank Secrecy Act, and the banks complain nothing has replaced them.

The case the banks are making

The Bank Policy Institute builds its request on one principle: identical activity carrying identical risk should face identical rules. Its members run customer identification programmes, transaction monitoring and suspicious-activity reporting under close examination by their regulators, and they pay heavily for it. Meanwhile, the letter argues, funds that leave regulated exchanges can move through unhosted wallets, decentralized exchanges, mixers and cross-chain bridges with little or no anti-money-laundering oversight. The asymmetry matters practically too. A bank sees only the fiat endpoints of a crypto journey: the money going out to an exchange and, sometimes, the money coming back. Everything in between happens on public blockchains and through software the bank cannot see into or report on. The letter puts particular emphasis on secondary markets, the trading that happens after tokens are first issued. It points to the April 2026 stablecoin proposal under the GENIUS Act, which placed most illicit stablecoin activity in secondary trading. Beyond designation, it asks for targeted legislation, statutory authority to sanction mixers, whole-of-chain information sharing, and bank-level due diligence for state-licensed money transmitters.

The numbers behind the request

The letter leans on two figures that have framed the debate about illicit crypto activity this year. The first comes from Chainalysis, whose data the letter cites as showing that illicit addresses received 154 billion dollars in 2025, up 162 percent from a year earlier. That measures value flowing into addresses Chainalysis links to illicit activity, not proof that all of it was criminal proceeds, nor that it passed through decentralized finance. Even so, the banks argue the trend shows the framework losing ground. The second figure is tied to a single event: the theft from Binance on October 29, which the Federal Bureau of Investigation attributed to North Korea. The Bank Policy Institute cites the analytics firm TRM Labs’ estimate that 6.36 billion dollars left the exchange’s wallets in the attack, making it the largest crypto theft on record. A theft of that scale, attributed to a sanctioned state actor, concentrates minds in Washington, and the letter arrived eight days later.

Advertisement

Where a bank’s view of a transfer stops

The most persuasive part of the letter may be its worked example, which follows a customer it calls Customer A through a five-hop journey that begins and ends at a bank. Customer A sends 1,000 dollars from a bank into crypto, through a self-hosted wallet and a mixer, and back to the bank, and the letter maps exactly who can see what at each stage. In the first hop, the bank sees the customer’s identity and an outgoing payment, and the reporting duty sits with the bank. In the second, the exchange sees the account data, the buy order and the withdrawal address, and the duty sits with the exchange. In the third hop, the funds sit in a self-hosted wallet, where all anyone can see is an address and amounts on a public ledger, with no name attached, and there is no reporting duty for an owner moving their own funds. In the fourth hop, the funds pass through a mixer, where deposits and withdrawals from a shared pool are visible but the link between them is broken, and a duty exists only if a business runs the mixer. In the fifth hop, the funds return through an exchange to the bank, and the duty sits with the exchange and the bank, each for its own leg. The letter accepts analytics can rebuild parts of such a chain, but argues that cannot replace reporting from the intermediary that dealt with the customer, and a reporting duty only produces information where the duty-holder has some to report.

What the law already reaches, and what control means

The letter says unhosted wallets and mixers carry no Bank Secrecy Act obligations, but the legal picture is more finely drawn than that. FinCEN’s own 2019 guidance on convertible virtual currency draws the line by function rather than by label. A person using an unhosted wallet to move their own funds is not a money transmitter. But an anonymizing service that accepts customers’ crypto and sends it onward is a money transmitter, with registration, compliance programme and reporting duties, while a company that only supplies anonymizing software is not. The same guidance judges decentralized applications by what they do: writing the code does not make a developer a money transmitter, but using the application to run a money transmission business for others can. The real gap is narrower than the word mixers suggests: it sits with mixing performed entirely by code that no business operates, and that is where enforcement has already hit a wall. In Van Loon v. Department of the Treasury, decided in November 2024, the Fifth Circuit held that Tornado Cash’s immutable smart contracts are not property under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, so the Office of Foreign Assets Control lacked authority to sanction them. The ruling binds only that circuit, yet it explains why the Bank Policy Institute asks Congress, rather than Treasury, for power over mixers. The letter borrows its test from the Financial Action Task Force, whose July 2026 report asks whether someone keeps control or sufficient influence even when smart contracts execute the trades. The indicators are concrete: administrator keys that can pause or alter contracts, authority to push upgrades, and governance votes concentrated in a few hands.

The other side, and what to watch next

Treasury’s own notices supply the opposing case, and it deserves a fair hearing. In withdrawing the mixing measure, FinCEN cited the July 2025 report of the President’s Working Group on Digital Asset Markets, which acknowledged lawful users may use mixers for privacy on public blockchains. The agency also said the measure risked chilling legitimate activity and loading covered institutions with reporting that would not produce useful intelligence. Crypto policy groups go further. Coin Center, which opposed all three proposals, had warned that the 250-dollar threshold would push ordinary payments into what it called warrantless financial surveillance. Ji Hun Kim, chief executive of the Crypto Council for Innovation, said in a statement on X that dropping the threshold change was the right decision because of the burden it would have placed on institutions. Congress has already rejected one attempt to push reporting into decentralized finance: in April 2025, it used the Congressional Review Act to repeal an Internal Revenue Service rule that would have treated some decentralized-finance front ends as tax brokers. If Treasury adopted the approach, front ends run by an identifiable company might have to request identification before a wallet connects, while fully immutable protocols would remain outside that reach unless Congress acted. Two markers will show Treasury’s direction: FinCEN’s section of the next semiannual Unified Agenda, and whether Treasury asks Congress for authority to sanction mixers.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Bank Policy Institute asking FinCEN to do?

Advertisement

It wants FinCEN and the Office of Foreign Assets Control to designate digital-asset service providers and people who operate or control decentralized finance arrangements as financial institutions under the Bank Secrecy Act, bringing them inside the identification, monitoring and reporting regime banks follow.

Why did FinCEN withdraw three crypto proposals?

FinCEN tied the October 5 withdrawals to the administration’s deregulatory agenda, and called the 2020 plan to cut the Travel Rule threshold from 3,000 dollars to 250 dollars stale after more than five years.

Does the 3,000-dollar Travel Rule threshold still apply?

Advertisement

Yes. The withdrawal of the plan to cut it to 250 dollars takes effect with Federal Register publication on November 9, leaving the 3,000-dollar trigger in the existing cross-border recordkeeping rule in force.

Would this affect ordinary people using decentralized finance?

Possibly, at front ends run by identifiable companies, which might have to request identification before a wallet connects. Fully immutable protocols with no operator would stay outside that reach unless Congress passed new legislation.

Source: CryptoFused

Advertisement

—

Related reading on MM Crypto Analysis Web

More in Regulation on MM Crypto Analysis Web.

Advertisement
Advertisement

MM Crypto Team

MM Crypto Team covers crypto news, prices and market analysis.

One thought on “Banks Ask FinCEN to Bring DeFi Under Bank Secrecy Act Reporting”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement