
Aave and Morpho Take Competing DeFi Lending Frameworks to the SEC
Decentralised finance has spent years waiting for a clear answer to its most important legal question: when does on-chain lending stop being software and start being a security? In the space of a few weeks, two of the biggest names in decentralised lending have handed the United States Securities and Exchange Commission their own answers, and the two answers do not agree. Aave Labs, together with Veda Tech Labs and the Kamino Foundation, has submitted a legal framework arguing that decentralised lending protocols and non-custodial vaults fall outside federal securities law. Separately, a coalition led by Morpho, Bitwise and Galaxy, working through the Crypto Council for Innovation, has submitted a far longer report that takes a different route to a similar destination, drawing the line at the amount of human control exercised over a vault. The result is the most significant regulatory moment for DeFi lending since the SEC began bringing enforcement cases against centralised crypto lenders, and the outcome will shape how lending protocols, vault curators and the mainstream platforms built on top of them operate in the United States for years to come.
Two frameworks, one question
The two submissions arrived within days of each other, and the contrast between them is striking. The Crypto Council for Innovation published its report, titled Under Control: A Framework for Applying the Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Vaults, on October 29, 2026. Running to roughly 238 pages and written by the law firm Chapman and Cutler, it was developed through the council’s Vault Coalition, whose participants include Morpho, Bitwise and Galaxy. The Aave camp moved first in private and second in public: on October 26, Aave Labs, Veda Tech Labs and the Kamino Foundation submitted a more detailed confidential version of their framework to the SEC’s Crypto Task Force and its Division of Corporation Finance, and asked for a meeting with SEC staff. On November 2, the three organisations published a 16-page public summary of their position.
Both documents begin from the same place. They look back at the centralised lending platforms that the SEC pursued in recent years, most notably BlockFi, whose interest-bearing accounts the SEC determined in 2022 were securities, a finding that ended in a settlement worth 100 million dollars paid to the SEC and several states. They also note the collapse of Celsius, whose bankruptcy exposed how much risk customers had taken on when a company held their assets and promised them returns. The two new frameworks argue that on-chain lending works differently in ways that matter legally. When a user deposits a stablecoin such as USDC into Aave, the funds remain inside a smart contract, and no company takes ownership of them. Borrowers must first deposit collateral worth more than the loan they want, and if the value of that collateral falls below a liquidation threshold, independent third parties step in to sell it. Interest rates are not set by a manager’s judgement but calculated automatically by a public formula based on how heavily each pool is being used. On that basis, both camps conclude that ordinary overcollateralised lending is not a security, and that depositors are not buying an investment contract when they supply assets to a lending protocol.
What the Morpho camp proposes
Where the Crypto Council for Innovation framework becomes distinctive is in how it handles vaults. A vault is not a simple lending pool. It adds a layer of human judgement, because a curator chooses how to allocate deposits between different markets and strategies. The council’s report proposes that this human element should be the deciding factor. It puts forward what it calls a two-sided control framework, examining both the authority retained by the curator and the practical control still available to the depositor. Strategies governed by fixed rules, with limited human intervention, would have the strongest case for sitting outside securities law. As a curator’s discretion grows, and as depositors lose the practical ability to understand or exit a strategy, the case for treating the vault as a security grows stronger. The report is said to set out ten verifiable criteria for making that judgement, together with a roadmap for exemptions that could give compliant vaults a clear path forward.
What the Aave camp argues
Aave Labs, Veda Tech Labs and the Kamino Foundation take a different view, and their disagreement with the council’s approach is the heart of this story. They argue that making human discretion the deciding factor is too restrictive, and that it could have serious consequences for business models that already exist, including their own. Their framework contends that even actively managed vaults and lending protocols governed by a decentralised autonomous organisation, or DAO, can fall outside securities law, provided the arrangements do not create the legal relationships those laws were designed to regulate. In their reading, the key questions are who owns the assets, whether a common investment enterprise exists, and whether there is an issuer standing behind the product. When users retain ownership of their assets, when there is no common enterprise pooling their fortunes together, and when no issuer is promising them returns, a manager’s investment decisions alone are not enough to create a security or an investment company.
The Aave camp’s argument leans on both the Howey test and the Reves test, the second of which is used in lending contexts to judge whether an arrangement counts as a security. It also raises a question under the Investment Company Act, which regulates pooled investment vehicles, arguing that a protocol which simply operates a market should not be treated as a fund. Linda Jeng, Aave’s chief legal and policy officer, has framed the point in practical terms, arguing that communities publicly setting market rules and giving users clear windows to exit amounts to operating a market rather than managing other people’s money. That distinction matters enormously for DAOs, because token holders in a lending protocol routinely vote on risk parameters such as collateral limits and interest rate models. If every such adjustment were treated as investment management, the Aave camp warns, the everyday governance of a decentralised protocol could itself become a regulated activity.
Where both sides agree
For all their disagreement, the two camps share more ground than the headlines suggest. Both accept that ordinary overcollateralised lending, where a smart contract holds the funds and a public formula sets the rates, is not a security. Both acknowledge that the old centralised lending cases do not map neatly onto decentralised protocols, because the custody, the decision-making and the risk all sit in different places. And both sides agree on at least one point that matters to a large part of the industry: providing paid investment advice that involves securities may still fall under regulation through the Investment Advisers Act, even if the underlying vault or protocol is not itself a security. That shared concession is important, because it shows neither camp is arguing for a regulation-free zone. Both are arguing about where the boundary should sit, not whether a boundary should exist at all.
What happens next at the SEC
Neither submission is a final answer, and the SEC is under no obligation to adopt either one. What happens next is likely to be a slow process of meetings, staff analysis and further public guidance, rather than a single dramatic ruling. The Aave camp has already asked for a meeting with SEC staff, and the Crypto Task Force has been gathering industry views on vaults and other DeFi structures for months. The agency may respond with a staff statement, a no-action letter covering a specific fact pattern, or a broader rulemaking effort, but none of those outcomes is guaranteed, and the history of crypto regulation suggests that clarity often arrives gradually, through a series of smaller steps, rather than all at once.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main disagreement between Aave and Morpho on DeFi lending regulation?
Both camps agree that ordinary overcollateralised lending is not a security, but they disagree about vaults where a manager allocates funds. The Morpho-backed Crypto Council for Innovation framework treats the degree of human control and discretion as the key factor, while Aave Labs, Veda Tech Labs and the Kamino Foundation argue that user ownership and the absence of a common enterprise should exempt vaults even when they are actively managed.
What did the Crypto Council for Innovation submit to the SEC?
The council published a roughly 238-page report called Under Control on October 29, 2026, written by the law firm Chapman and Cutler and developed through its Vault Coalition with Morpho, Bitwise and Galaxy. It proposes a two-sided control framework with ten verifiable criteria for judging when a crypto vault should be treated as a security.
What did Aave Labs, Veda and Kamino submit to the SEC?
The three organisations submitted a detailed confidential framework to the SEC’s Crypto Task Force and Division of Corporation Finance on October 26, 2026, and published a 16-page public summary on November 2. They argue that decentralised lending protocols and non-custodial vaults are not subject to federal securities law, based on the Howey and Reves tests and the Investment Company Act.
Has the SEC decided whether crypto vaults are securities?
No. The SEC has not approved either framework and has not granted a general exemption to DeFi vaults. SEC staff have updated their guidance on crypto asset investment contracts, and former commissioner Hester Peirce has sought industry feedback on vaults, but individual products remain subject to fact-specific legal analysis.
Source: Coin Newsify
—
Related reading on MM Crypto Analysis Web
- Aave DAO Approves Native Bitcoin as Collateral in Aave V4 via Babylon Vaults
- Coinbase Adds DeFi Tokens SKY and USDS to Its Trading Platform
- Aave Debuts on Sony-Backed Soneium Blockchain
More in DeFi on MM Crypto Analysis Web.
Pingback: KelpDAO Exploit Ethereum Liquidity Drain Hits $38.4 Billion